Claims Information
Any time you have a claim to report it can be a stressful and traumatic time. Ginnie Schimelpfenig and Brooke Bowers are the liaisons between you, our insured, and the company you are insured with. Please call them with your claims reports or complete a claim report . They will answer your questions and also help you with your initial report. Our claims department is here on your behalf to assist you through the claims process and ensure you have a swift and fair claims settlement.
You can call your agent directly if you wish. You will find those phone numbers in the employee directory.
If you have recently had a claims experience with us, we invite you to complete the survey below. Please click on the button to start the survey.

Here are some suggestions that may be helpful in the event of a claim:
- It's always best to take photos immediately after the incident with the following documentation: Who, What, When Where
- Property Claims: Proect yourself first! After that, take the necessary measures to protect the insured property from further damage. Reasonagle epenses incurred to protect and preserve the property after a covered loss are reimbursable (above your deductible). Emergency repairs should also be made to proect remaining property or prevent injury to people.
- Separate the damaged from the undamaged items. Make a list of the items damaged and include the item's age and value.
- All theft losses must be reported to the police as soon as possible.
- Liability Claims: Observe details at the scene of the accident and note what may have caused the accident. Did hazardous conditions exist or did the injured party cause the accident. Get the following details; Date, time and location of the accident. Name, address and phone number of the injured party. Get names and addresses of any witnesses to the accident.
- Automobile Claims: Do not discuss responsibility for the accident at the scene. Advise the other parties you will turn the claim in to your insurance gent for handling. Give them your insurance information. Accidents causing either bodily injury or property damage in excess of $500 mut be reported to the Department of Motor Vehicles within 10 days by filing an SR-1 form that the attending police officer should provide.
If it is after hours and an emergency, please contact your insurance carrier directly to report your claim. We have listed their 800 number claims service below. If there is a separate after hours number we have listed that as well. Please have your policy number ready. After reporting your claim, you should expect to be contacted by the insurance company adjuster withing 24 hours.
| AIG |
Workers Compensation 1-877-802-5246
P & C 1-913-338-9200 |
| Acuity |
New Claims 1-800-242-7666 |
| Allied Insurance |
New 1-800-532-1212
Workers Compensation 1-877-562-3115
Glass Claim 1-800-981-9891 |
| Auto Owners |
New 1-888-685-9618 |
| Badger Insurance |
New Claims 1-800-837-7833 |
| Central Insurance |
New Claims 1-800-241-2541 |
| Continental Western |
New Claims 1-877-643-0219 |
| General Casualty |
New 1-800-892-1177 |
| Grange Insurance |
New Claims 1-800-445-3030
Glass (Call Safelite) 1-800-951-9734 |
| Great American |
New Claims 1-800-297-1971 |
| The Hartford |
New Claims 1-877-230-3084
Towing 1-800-RESCUE
Glass 1-800-892-8484 if not repaired
Glass (repaired) FAX info to 1-614-210-9502 |
| Illinois Fair Plan |
1-312-861-0385 |
| Indiana Insurance |
|
| Kemper |
New Claims 1-888-252-2799 |
| Nationwide Ag |
New 1-800-228-6700 |
| One Beacon |
New 1-877-248-4968 |
| Philadelphia |
New Claims 1-800-765-9749 |
| Progressive |
New Claims 1-800-274-4641 |
| Sentry |
New Claims 1-800-558-9257 |
| Society |
New Claims 1-888-576-2438 |
| State Auto |
New Claims 1-800-766-1853
Workers Compensation Fax 1-800-410-7317 |
| Travelers |
New Claims 1-800-787-2851 |
| United Fire Group |
New Claims 1-800-343-9131 |
| West Bend Mutual |
New Claims 1-800-236-5003 or 877-922-5246
Glass Claim 1-800-334-4665 |
| Westfield Group |
New Claim 1-309-693-7400
Glas Claim 1-800-810-3665 |
| Zurich |
New Claim 1-800-561-7812 |